Off Broadway Deli & Pizza in New York City

Just found this place. Amazing food. Great service. Cute store!

Food is absolutely amazing recommend everyone to go try a bite customer service is extremely kind

Great food, great service. Both soups were amazing and we all enjoyed our sandwiches. I will be going again.

A friend and I go to lunch at Off Broadway a couple times a month. Great sandwiches and great staff.

Great food and friendley service

Best sandwich I've had in years!!! Highly recommend!!!

Great food at good prices. Some of the best finger steaks.

The best food and service you could ever ask for.

Most delicious grilled Hawaiian sandwich! Love this place! Interior is very calming and welcoming, menu has lots of options and cutest of all - it has a little library in there!

Whoa. This place kicks butt. I was not excited about a deli for lunch (it was a group decision) but after eating here we will definitely be back. Going to a restaurant twice on a short visit to a new city is not something I like to do because I want to try so many places, but I need to try more items on their menu. Their fried chicken was incredible. The sandwiches were top notch. They gave me a taste of some of their soups and, holy cow. I am going back so I can get a whole bowl of some of their soups. Great stuff.

Had the "Rachel" sandwich. Corn beef on marble rye. Awesome!

Best ladies, that make the best sandwich. Love this place

Great sweet and friendly staff. Food is delicious

I loved my Reuben!

Excellent local deli, fresh bread, fresh meats, quality sandwiches! Clean location, decent parking.

Very friendly staff. Pictured below is The Hot Broad. Very delicious sandwich. The pesto was the best part. The fries are great too, will be back!!

There is something magic about the food in this place. I ordered the Hot Broad and it was perhaps one of the best sandwiches and I've had in years. Their fries are without a doubt the best I've ever had....and I eat a lot of sandwiches and fries. Even my kid's simple turkey and Swiss were full of flavor well above the expectations for such a simple sandwich... Service and staff are top-notch. I don't know how you pack so much flavor in your sandwiches.. but the world would be a better place if all sandwiches were this good.

The only thing preventing 5 stars is their potato salad was no different than the gallon stuff you buy in a cardboard box from Walmart. The sandwiches themselves can't be beat! Great price, great quality, and lots of customizable options.

Love this place. The owners are awesome, staff is friendly food is delicious.

Very yummy sandwiches. We had the Hawaiian. It was delicious. We love their french fries but they were out.

Not impressed. We 4 came for lunch today and was disappointed. The aroma was not of meats and breads as uOne would expect. It smelled of old cooking oil There were NO SIDES. NO soupNO friesNO CHICKEN..our sandwhiches were soggy even though we asked for them to be to TToasted. The breads are from a grocery store... not homemade. We were very dissatisfied to say the least. Our sandwhiches were the same as sold at any cafe or Dennys. 🤔🤨😳 We came here cuz the reviews and the webpage SUGGESTED more than they offer. 👎👎👎👎

Great Sandwich Shop. Try the Pilgrim on toasted sourdough.

Simply the best in town! We love this place! The ladies are the sweetest and the food is amazing and for a great price.

Fresh amazing sandwiches! The Italian grinder is my favorite menu item. Go and try their delicious deli sandwiches today. Highly recommend.

Dinner here with some friends. Staff is friendly, food is tasty. What more do you need?

This place has a "soup girl" that makes hands down some of the best soup I have ever had. Please make the lemon artichoke a regular...it was incredible and I crave it everyday.

Great owners and customer service. Best sandwiches in the state hands down !! Even wrote this note for my daughter on her birthday. Always a go to destination.

Always clean and fresh. Staff is always friendly and helpful.

Love the sandwiches! Love the people! What more can I say.

Yummy sandwich!! I had a turkey, bacon, avocado and it was great! High quality ingredients and plenty of turkey 😁 Highly recommend!

It was my first time there food was very good the service was excellent.

I really like the food here. It's a cleaner fresher version of Hugo's Deli. There is a sandwich for everyone. Don't shy away from anything that sounds a little weird. I tend to find that those are the most amazing sandwiches. So jump right in, don't foget the potato wedges or fries or whatever they call them, they are great to.

This place is amazing! It is a hidden gem. I discovered it a week ago and I am in love of this place. Try anything with the pesto sauce. It is epic !!

It was disappointing to place an order two hours prior with permission to pick it up 10 minutes after they close, only to find that when we arrived early just 3 minutes after they closed with no one to greet us as promised with our order. Very disappointing, I won't bother to stop when traveling ever again. Even Stevens had a wonderful Reuben sandwich.

The food and as good but the place was COLD! It's winter for Pete's sake and they need a heater! The person who rang up my order said they don't have one at all, how is that even possible? In the future I'd get my food to go from here in the winter.

Stay away from the somewhat salty soups, but done in, do, into the best fried chicken in town.

Off Broadway Deli is a cool little deli that I have had the pleasure of growing up with. The food is always great and the staff friendly. It is really neat to see the same faces when you go in from way back in the Hugo’s days. A true stapleIn our community!

Great sandwiches and deli fries. Lovely lady's will help you with your orders and make it your way if needed.

Pre-quarantine I enjoyed this spot. Since mask wearing has been the norm/expected procedure, I do not enjoy this place. Employees took their masks off to talk to me, coughed into their hands, and gave me things I did not order on my sandwich which I’m allergic to, which is infuriating. I fully expect orders to have the occasional order when it’s busy, but when I’m the only order in the building, I expect a higher accuracy. Also the employee telling me she was only wearing a mask to keep her job was a bit disappointing & off putting.

Food was good but not completive with major venders.

Sandwich was good. Potato salad was good. And soda. Service was good...14 dollars for the items seemed a but much.

This is the place to go for great sandwiches.

I love the food there cause we always get the best service

Fresh, excellent food, and friendly employees! I eat gluten free and they are able to make any sandwich into a salad. I had the Italian and the portion was very generous. It was superb! We were heading home on a road trip, but I almost want to get back in the car and go back to Boise ID just to eat there again!

Delicious sandwich. Delicious soup. Pleasant service. I loved it.

I really can't complain about them. I tried, I picked sandwiches I knew I wasn't a big fan of, and they were still decent. I get a different sandwich every time and they never disappoint. I even tried their Chicken Pot Pie soup today, it was delicious. Only thing I wish could change is they need more locations!

I dig this place. Each time I visit the employees are respectful and appreciative of my business. They're some down chics! Sandwiches I've had and enjoyed include The Hot Broad (turkey, pesto, and swiss -yum), and a meatball sub. They're both great, but make sure you order their deli fries along with your sandwich. Perfectly cooked! Head on over and support a local business, and leave with a full belly.

Love the food! My only issue is I don't think the servers stir the soup before dishing it up. I always get a ton of broth with barely anything in it.😭

Frsh Deli sandwiches which are heavy on flavor